Pundits Versus Scientists

A Battle for the Soul of America

I’ve been a pundit. I’ve been a scientist. And I can tell you, from personal experience, that the two jobs could not be more different. While some scientists play the role of pundits, it often comes at a cost to their work as scientists. And when some pundits pretend to be scientists, it is a ploy to use the respect that science has earned to advance their own political and personal agendas.

All too often, our public discourse has failed to note the distinction between these roles. It’s related to another failure, which may be unavoidable in a market-oriented media system. There are very few actual journalists. These are people dedicated to telling you the truth, often at their own expense, that people in power don’t want you to hear. Most practicing reporters aren’t journalists. They take a press release and call names from their lists of contacts to provide the “expert analysis” that lends an air of objectivity to their work. Given the time pressure built into their job, that’s often…